Whats Better For My Shop, a Mini-Split or Garage Heater?

Comfy isn’t often a word used to reference a garage. But many homeowners make the most of this area as a workshop for home improvement projects or hobbies like woodworking. Considering using your garage for a home woodshop? By installing heating and cooling, you’ll be able to enjoy the garage throughout the year.

Common systems, like a furnace, heat pump or air conditioner, are typically pricey because of the ductwork that’s required. Also, garages are sometimes not connected to your home.

The two most frequently used solutions are garage heaters or mini-split systems, since they don’t need ductwork. But which kind should you select? It’s critical to be aware of each to select the most energy-efficient solution for your situation. Sawdust requires special consideration because these particles can bog down filters and lower your system’s efficiency.

We review the differences to help you choose the ideal solution for your needs.

Mini-Splits: Ideal for Heating and Cooling

Ductless mini-splits are similar to a heat pump, as they shift heat in place of making it. This makes them very energy efficient. They’re mounted on your wall and link to an outside unit via a small hole in the wall.

A mini-split air conditioner is popular for its energy efficiency and nearly silent operation. This makes it ideal for craftsmen looking for a calm, cozy area to work. Because they deliver both heating and cooling, mini-splits can be used all year round.

Since wood shrinks with changes in temperature, total control over heating and cooling is very advantageous. Most carpenters and woodworkers recommend finishing projects in temperatures much like where the final product will end up.

Checking your filter consistently is a critical part of service. Cutting creates a lot of sawdust. If you don’t clean your mini-split’s filter, you risk reducing your system’s efficiency and longevity.

A mini-split also requires regular service from a certified HVAC tech, like one from McElroy Service Experts. Keeping its internal pieces clean and lubricated will help lower the likelihood of interruptions in comfort and could even help it run for an extended period of time.

Garage Heaters: Ideal for Cold Climates

Garage heaters operate slightly differently. They make heat, so it’s better to compare one to a miniature furnace. They’re fixed on the ceiling, often in a corner. If you turn to your garage for added storage, consider the fact that these heaters will take up a part the overhead room.

The biggest difference between garage heaters and mini-split systems is the type of fuel they need, as mini-splits are electric. Propane or natural gas garage heaters are both standard types, but there are electric garage heaters also if you don’t want to bother with fuel hookups.

Garage heaters include a bonus that gives them a leg up on a mini-split system. They don’t require a filter and some models have closed combustion chambers, which stops sawdust from getting into those internal pieces.

Key Variations Between Mini-Splits and Garage Heaters

In the end there are lots of things to keep in mind, like the temperatures in Grand Island. These include:

  • Whether you need both heating and cooling, or merely heating.
  • Your budget.
  • How much wall area you have in your shop.
  • How much time and money you want to devote to tune-ups.

Ductless mini-split systems are great if you want versatility and peak energy efficiency. They offer both heating and cooling, making them the best style for zoned climate control. But this efficiency comes at a price. Mini-split heat pumps are more expensive up front than garage heaters. If you don’t plan on using your garage frequently, this may not be the most budget-friendly solution. But woodshops in climates with major adjustments in temperature may benefit from better control.

Garage heaters are a simpler, more affordable option. Different models use differing fuel sources to create heat only, making them ill-suited for hotter areas. Gas or propane garage heaters are great if fuel costs are more reasonable. They’re not as energy efficient, so regular use may result in higher utility expenses. But the excellent heat generation is recommended in northern climates.

For trustworthy advice and installation, trust the HVAC Experts at McElroy Service Experts. We’ll help you make the ideal choice. And with outstanding repair and maintenance services, your garage will be a relaxing area for many years to come. Reach us at 308-210-4398 to book a free home comfort assessment or appointment right away.

Contact Us